What do you think?
Rate this book
ソラニン [Solanin] #1-2
Solanin
Meiko Inoue is a recent college grad working as an office lady in a job she hates. Her boyfriend Naruo is permanently crashing at her apartment because his job as a freelance illustrator doesn't pay enough for rent. And her parents in the country keep sending her boxes of veggies that just rot in her fridge. Straddling the line between her years as a student and the rest of her life, Meiko struggles with the feeling that she's just not cut out to be a part of the real world.
432 pages, Paperback
First published October 21, 2006
About the author
Inio Asano
107 books2,233 followersInio Asano (浅野いにお Asano Inio, born September 22, 1980 in Ishioka, Ibaraki Prefecture, Japan) is a Japanese manga author. Asano created the acclaimed manga Solanin which was released as a feature film in Japan in April 2010, starring Aoi Miyazaki. He is known for his character driven, realist stories that range from slice of life stories to psychological horror. In 2001 he won the first prize in the GX competition for young manga artists.
The Yomiuri Shimbun newspaper described him as "one of the voices of his generation."
Instagram: asano_inio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inio_Asano
The Yomiuri Shimbun newspaper described him as "one of the voices of his generation."
Instagram: asano_inio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inio_Asano
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,236 reviews
April 8, 2024
This captures for the artist, then 24, that time of his life, and for others, the time between young adulthood and adulthood, where you fear you may be selling out your dreams and every day pleasures for boring, regimented, uncreative adult life. This is a novel told from the perspective of a young girl, Meiko, 24, who has been in a relationship for 6 years with Naruo. She hates her office girl job, he works part time illustrating but wants to be in a band even if they aren't spectacular. The band is a symbol of creativity and living one's passion and dreams. . . sound familiar? Still, it feels real, true to that age. I felt like that then, for sure.
The art is good, the main character is engaging, really likable, and as the artist says himself in an afterword, this isn't about superheroes and not even supercool people but just average, every day people, a slice of life anyone can relate to. And from my perusing some of the other twenty-something reviews, he captures the spirit of the twenties, as they found it moving. I liked it a lot, too.
The art is good, the main character is engaging, really likable, and as the artist says himself in an afterword, this isn't about superheroes and not even supercool people but just average, every day people, a slice of life anyone can relate to. And from my perusing some of the other twenty-something reviews, he captures the spirit of the twenties, as they found it moving. I liked it a lot, too.
January 2, 2023
Inio Asano’s slice-of-life manga reflects Asano’s own anxieties after graduating from college and attempting to establish a career as a manga author. Originally serialised and targeting an audience close in age to Asano’s central characters, Solanin treads a fine line between angst-ridden and muted. It follows the experiences of Mieko, in her twenties, her low-level office job is suffocating and her relationship with her live-in boyfriend Taneda’s precarious. Asano’s story charts the consequences of her decision to leave her job in an attempt to find some form of freedom, a move that’s then unexpectedly marred by tragedy.
Mieko’s situation’s a familiar one - Asano’s representation of alienated graduates struggling to cope with an uncertain, perilous world is not especially original - but it’s still incredibly relevant and relatable. Gradually Mieko and her circle of friends are confronted with the nature of time and fleeting youth, and the need to embrace life for what it is. I had some issues with the structure, the plot moves backwards and forwards in time, and sometimes it took me a while to realise I’d been plunged into Mieko’s past. But I liked the willingness to mix realism and fantasy, and the sense of sincerity driving this. Asano’s style’s understated, and the images sharply realist, mixing the visual and the verbal in satisfying ways. Asano also includes photographic images that have been drawn over adding to the impression of immediacy and realism. Overall, it’s a well-crafted piece and there were plenty of enjoyable elements but at the same time I was never fully invested in Mieko’s journey.
Mieko’s situation’s a familiar one - Asano’s representation of alienated graduates struggling to cope with an uncertain, perilous world is not especially original - but it’s still incredibly relevant and relatable. Gradually Mieko and her circle of friends are confronted with the nature of time and fleeting youth, and the need to embrace life for what it is. I had some issues with the structure, the plot moves backwards and forwards in time, and sometimes it took me a while to realise I’d been plunged into Mieko’s past. But I liked the willingness to mix realism and fantasy, and the sense of sincerity driving this. Asano’s style’s understated, and the images sharply realist, mixing the visual and the verbal in satisfying ways. Asano also includes photographic images that have been drawn over adding to the impression of immediacy and realism. Overall, it’s a well-crafted piece and there were plenty of enjoyable elements but at the same time I was never fully invested in Mieko’s journey.
September 15, 2019
--Solanin
Afterword
Afterword
August 5, 2009
Solanin is by far one of the best reads I have personally ever had. It's a wonderfully crafted story with the most character, charm, and personality a graphic novel has had in quite some time. I felt all emotions while flipping through theses pages and no other story had produced so many tears for me. Although it's sort of a depressing story, the answer that Inio Asano gives us is perserverance and hope. Solanin is a must read.
The main character Meiko, is a relatable girl. She's been out of collage for just a few years, worked an office job, and realizes soemthing--she's bored. Her place in life is not exactly what she wants, but she is content. This predicament causes her to question her happiness and what that really is. Her story is one that every person goes through at one point or another and in some form. Meiko is representative of the modern woman and the crazy society that moves around us.
The book also dives into the minds of Meiko's boyfriend and her friends from college. They all are around the same age and although they are doing different things with their lives, they are all questioning life, its meaning, and what they want out of it. With so many characters' insights and opinions there is always something to get out of the text. I find myself going over quotes from the book during everyday moments and also thinking, "This is just like Solanin."
In addition to Asano's flawless use of words, she illustrates her novel with stunningly drawn japanse anime style pictures. Basically, the book is like a thick manga with more of a serious plot devolopment. Don't let this throw you off though. You do not need to be a anime of manga fan to enjoy this read. Its soul and feel will whisk you away to the point where you won't even realize there are images on the page.
Solanin is a masterpiece in itself. It is pure magic that will
captivate your attention. I read this whole book in just a few hours because I could not bring myself to put the thing down. Once you get a feel of who these characters are and what their lives are like, you will never forget them and they will stay in your heart forever. It's not very often that an author can create something like that.
The main character Meiko, is a relatable girl. She's been out of collage for just a few years, worked an office job, and realizes soemthing--she's bored. Her place in life is not exactly what she wants, but she is content. This predicament causes her to question her happiness and what that really is. Her story is one that every person goes through at one point or another and in some form. Meiko is representative of the modern woman and the crazy society that moves around us.
The book also dives into the minds of Meiko's boyfriend and her friends from college. They all are around the same age and although they are doing different things with their lives, they are all questioning life, its meaning, and what they want out of it. With so many characters' insights and opinions there is always something to get out of the text. I find myself going over quotes from the book during everyday moments and also thinking, "This is just like Solanin."
In addition to Asano's flawless use of words, she illustrates her novel with stunningly drawn japanse anime style pictures. Basically, the book is like a thick manga with more of a serious plot devolopment. Don't let this throw you off though. You do not need to be a anime of manga fan to enjoy this read. Its soul and feel will whisk you away to the point where you won't even realize there are images on the page.
Solanin is a masterpiece in itself. It is pure magic that will
captivate your attention. I read this whole book in just a few hours because I could not bring myself to put the thing down. Once you get a feel of who these characters are and what their lives are like, you will never forget them and they will stay in your heart forever. It's not very often that an author can create something like that.
September 7, 2018
Don't date musicians.
Especially wannabe musicians.
Especially wannabe musicians.
April 26, 2024
"زندگی کردن واسه خیلیها مشکله. زندگی انقدر چیزهای مختلف داره که آدم گیج میشه ولی میدونم چیزی هست که ارزش زندگی کردن رو داره. اگه در کنار نوازندگی به این باور خودم وفادار بمونم، حس میکنم حتی شده یه ذره میتونم دنیا رو عوض کنم."
داستان سولانین در مورد یه دختر جوون به نام میکوعه که با دوست پسرش توی توکیو زندگی میکنن. میکو کارمنده ولی از وضع خودش و جامعه و مسیرش راضی نیست و حس میکنه یه جای کار رو اشتباه رفته و اینجایی که الان هست و چیزی که شده، با اون چیزی که توی ذهنش بوده و میخواسته بشه خیلی متفاوته. برای همین از کارش استعفا میده و ما باهاش همراه میشیم تا بالا و پایین زندگیش رو ببینیم و در نهایت بفهمیم به چه معنایی از زندگی میرسه.
این اثر، اولین کاری هست که از آسانو سنسی میخونم و با اون چیزی که معمولا در موردش گفته میشه متفاوت بود و خبری از اون فضای افسرده و دارک نبود. اتفاقا در نهایت حس و حال مثبتی داشت. با این حال چون اون فلسفه خاص زندگی که ارائه میکرد رو قبلا بهش رسیدم و برام آشنائه، اونقدرا شگفتزده نشدم.
داستان سولانین در مورد یه دختر جوون به نام میکوعه که با دوست پسرش توی توکیو زندگی میکنن. میکو کارمنده ولی از وضع خودش و جامعه و مسیرش راضی نیست و حس میکنه یه جای کار رو اشتباه رفته و اینجایی که الان هست و چیزی که شده، با اون چیزی که توی ذهنش بوده و میخواسته بشه خیلی متفاوته. برای همین از کارش استعفا میده و ما باهاش همراه میشیم تا بالا و پایین زندگیش رو ببینیم و در نهایت بفهمیم به چه معنایی از زندگی میرسه.
این اثر، اولین کاری هست که از آسانو سنسی میخونم و با اون چیزی که معمولا در موردش گفته میشه متفاوت بود و خبری از اون فضای افسرده و دارک نبود. اتفاقا در نهایت حس و حال مثبتی داشت. با این حال چون اون فلسفه خاص زندگی که ارائه میکرد رو قبلا بهش رسیدم و برام آشنائه، اونقدرا شگفتزده نشدم.
June 7, 2023
Amazing
February 24, 2016
{February 24th, 2016} COLLEGE LIFE AND BEGINNING ADULTHOOD
5 stars.
One of the books my brother got for his assignment and one I snuck away to read in one sitting. Inio Asano is considered one of the best selling and revered mangakas in Japan for his works. Hard to believe he rode and drew this around the age of 24. Hard to believe he did this after being unsure of his skills to succeed in the manga industry.
A poignant novel about where do we go after high school, college and university. New experiences and struggling to find what makes you happy in life, because at that point in your life you're supposed to have everything sorted out, no? Not everyone knows what they want to do in life, and will generally have the idea of what they do not wish to do as opposed to what they love. We forget how those that know and work hard towards it are fortunate to do so. Mostly because we've been constantly told don't work at something that makes you miserable for the rest of your life, well sometimes you don't get that kind of luxury.
I still find myself at a loss, and wondering if I'm walking the right path. And to be honest I cannot really imagine myself doing anything remotely outside the realm of books. But to get to that point, I have to struggle with the bad and ugly before I reach the good and fortunate.
What Solanin represents are the many insecurities we new adults have upon being thrust into the big open world. Whether you fight for your dreams or take a chance, and make bad choices amongst the good ones--life is full of surprises and turns. Although the story primarily follows Meiko, the rest of the cast get their chances in the spotlight remaining tight with the plot.
While it does speak to me, I cannot help but feel as though we've been missing these kinds of stories in the New Adult genre. There are so many points in life where we grow and mature, seek out our own futures however uncertain they may be--we need reassurance that it's okay not to know or to make mistakes.
And I think that's the heart of Solanin.
5 stars.
One of the books my brother got for his assignment and one I snuck away to read in one sitting. Inio Asano is considered one of the best selling and revered mangakas in Japan for his works. Hard to believe he rode and drew this around the age of 24. Hard to believe he did this after being unsure of his skills to succeed in the manga industry.
A poignant novel about where do we go after high school, college and university. New experiences and struggling to find what makes you happy in life, because at that point in your life you're supposed to have everything sorted out, no? Not everyone knows what they want to do in life, and will generally have the idea of what they do not wish to do as opposed to what they love. We forget how those that know and work hard towards it are fortunate to do so. Mostly because we've been constantly told don't work at something that makes you miserable for the rest of your life, well sometimes you don't get that kind of luxury.
I still find myself at a loss, and wondering if I'm walking the right path. And to be honest I cannot really imagine myself doing anything remotely outside the realm of books. But to get to that point, I have to struggle with the bad and ugly before I reach the good and fortunate.
What Solanin represents are the many insecurities we new adults have upon being thrust into the big open world. Whether you fight for your dreams or take a chance, and make bad choices amongst the good ones--life is full of surprises and turns. Although the story primarily follows Meiko, the rest of the cast get their chances in the spotlight remaining tight with the plot.
While it does speak to me, I cannot help but feel as though we've been missing these kinds of stories in the New Adult genre. There are so many points in life where we grow and mature, seek out our own futures however uncertain they may be--we need reassurance that it's okay not to know or to make mistakes.
And I think that's the heart of Solanin.
October 24, 2020
Đây là một cuốn truyện tranh gom vào mình vô vàn hoang mang của tuổi trẻ: ước mơ chông chênh, đam mê bỏ xó, tuổi xuân kiệt quệ... Mỗi một ngày trôi qua, gánh cơm áo gạo tiền oằn trĩu trên vai, đè cái nhiệt huyết bùng cháy tim gan dần dà tắt ngóm. Chẳng biết bấu víu vào đâu, ngoài những buộc ràng về tình cảm cũng đã chớm phai nhòa.
•
Ấy vậy mà, cục than đam mê nhỏ xíu kia vẫn âm ỉ tỏa lan giữa những người bạn, mặc sóng gió ào ạt tạt xối xả đến lịm người. Nước mắt đã rơi vì một nỗi đau quá lớn, đã hong khô chính những bờ vai kề sát bao năm trời. Họ đứng dậy, đẩy tinh thần, nâng sĩ khí, cùng nhau hát một bài hát thật hăng, say đến mụ mị, say đến quên đời.
•
Trong cuộc sống đầy những vướng bận bự tổ chảng này, đôi khi có một người bất thần chếnh choáng vì mầm độc solanin đến không thể gượng dậy, thì vẫn còn đó những vòng ôm thật chặt, những nụ cười hồ hởi, những sẻ chia trìu mến giúp mình, ta và tất cả vượt qua mọi thứ. Chỉ cần có lòng tin.
•
Ấy vậy mà, cục than đam mê nhỏ xíu kia vẫn âm ỉ tỏa lan giữa những người bạn, mặc sóng gió ào ạt tạt xối xả đến lịm người. Nước mắt đã rơi vì một nỗi đau quá lớn, đã hong khô chính những bờ vai kề sát bao năm trời. Họ đứng dậy, đẩy tinh thần, nâng sĩ khí, cùng nhau hát một bài hát thật hăng, say đến mụ mị, say đến quên đời.
•
Trong cuộc sống đầy những vướng bận bự tổ chảng này, đôi khi có một người bất thần chếnh choáng vì mầm độc solanin đến không thể gượng dậy, thì vẫn còn đó những vòng ôm thật chặt, những nụ cười hồ hởi, những sẻ chia trìu mến giúp mình, ta và tất cả vượt qua mọi thứ. Chỉ cần có lòng tin.
March 26, 2017
As I read this manga comic I realized something important about my reading tastes, namely, that while I love coming of age stories, I'm not as enamored by the "new adult" genre/stories. This book is the latter, hence the fact it doesn't get a higher rating is really because of that.
A term I see bandied about by Millennials is "Adutling." I often hear someone say "Adulting is hard." If you agree, this book is for you. Meiko is 24, a recent college grad, and working in a job that she hates. Her boyfriend, Naruo, isn't doing much better, and seems to have moved in with her, as with this part-time job he can't swing rent. The book follows both these characters as they struggle with the dreams they once had juxtaposed against the lives they are living. The black and white art is lovely, there are wonderfully poignant moments, and I liked it well enough.
A term I see bandied about by Millennials is "Adutling." I often hear someone say "Adulting is hard." If you agree, this book is for you. Meiko is 24, a recent college grad, and working in a job that she hates. Her boyfriend, Naruo, isn't doing much better, and seems to have moved in with her, as with this part-time job he can't swing rent. The book follows both these characters as they struggle with the dreams they once had juxtaposed against the lives they are living. The black and white art is lovely, there are wonderfully poignant moments, and I liked it well enough.
August 13, 2020
ive been crying for the past 2 hours
March 7, 2022
Cuando lees manga, el nombre de Inio Asano, surge una y otra vez a tu alrededor. Es difícil vencer la curiosidad de querer leer a un autor y dibujante tan reconocido tanto en Japón como de forma internacional. Sin embargo, tuve muy mal inicio y es que, no conseguí conectar con las primeras dos obras suyas que leí, que eran historias cortas. En otras ocasiones, dos intentos me hubieran hecho desistir de seguir leyendo un autor… pero, había algo que me llamaba a seguir probando. Así que me dije ¡es momento de ir con todo! Y me dispuse a leer “Solanin”, una obra larga publicada hace más de una década y amiguis… al fin, ¡Asano me ha enamorado!
“Solanin” presenta a un grupo de amigos, con personalidades complejas y trabajadas, en los años siguientes al fin de la universidad y donde todos se enfrentan al golpe que supone empezar a renunciar a los sueños de juventud en pos de una realidad marcada por la incertidumbre y la necesidad de trabajar para poder vivir. Vemos de cerca la vida de una pareja donde Meiko decide dejar un trabajo que no le gusta, mientras que Naruo quiere intentar una vez más triunfar con su grupo de música antes de ceder e introducirse de lleno en el mundo laboral. Conoceremos también las trabas de un chico que no consigue acabar la carrera y otro, que tiene la vida resulta porque trabaja en el negocio familiar, pero a quien ama, es inalcanzable. Es fácil identificarse con todos ellos en algún momento de nuestras vidas.
Me parece increíble como Asano recoge en esta obra muchísimos de los problemas e inquietudes de la juventud, enlazando el avance de la trama con un arte precioso (en serio, echadle un ojo a cualquiera de sus dibujos) que te hace sumergirte en cada trazo, creando una atmosfera sumamente real. Momentos dramáticos, otros llenos de humor y donde, sobre todo, la amistad tiene un papel fundamental para soportar los golpes y enfrentarse a la pérdida.
Esta edición se hizo para el 10º aniversario y une en un solo volumen los dos tomos con los que se publico inicialmente e incluye además, un capitulo extra, un epílogo creado por Asano expresamente para esta edición (que permite ver a los protagonistas 10 años después y que me pareció sumamente coherente) y un texto del autor reflexionando sobre “Solanin” años después de escribirla.
“Solanin” presenta a un grupo de amigos, con personalidades complejas y trabajadas, en los años siguientes al fin de la universidad y donde todos se enfrentan al golpe que supone empezar a renunciar a los sueños de juventud en pos de una realidad marcada por la incertidumbre y la necesidad de trabajar para poder vivir. Vemos de cerca la vida de una pareja donde Meiko decide dejar un trabajo que no le gusta, mientras que Naruo quiere intentar una vez más triunfar con su grupo de música antes de ceder e introducirse de lleno en el mundo laboral. Conoceremos también las trabas de un chico que no consigue acabar la carrera y otro, que tiene la vida resulta porque trabaja en el negocio familiar, pero a quien ama, es inalcanzable. Es fácil identificarse con todos ellos en algún momento de nuestras vidas.
Me parece increíble como Asano recoge en esta obra muchísimos de los problemas e inquietudes de la juventud, enlazando el avance de la trama con un arte precioso (en serio, echadle un ojo a cualquiera de sus dibujos) que te hace sumergirte en cada trazo, creando una atmosfera sumamente real. Momentos dramáticos, otros llenos de humor y donde, sobre todo, la amistad tiene un papel fundamental para soportar los golpes y enfrentarse a la pérdida.
Esta edición se hizo para el 10º aniversario y une en un solo volumen los dos tomos con los que se publico inicialmente e incluye además, un capitulo extra, un epílogo creado por Asano expresamente para esta edición (que permite ver a los protagonistas 10 años después y que me pareció sumamente coherente) y un texto del autor reflexionando sobre “Solanin” años después de escribirla.
February 9, 2023
No conocía a Inio Asano salvo de oídas por las redes sociales, pero siendo sincera cuando vi la portada de Solanin y sobre todo su sinopsis, tuve que sacarlo de la biblioteca con el presentimiento que iba a gustarme. Y no solo hecho, sino que ha superado todas mis expectativas y sorprendido lo que el autor se atreve a explorar en este manga.
Es una obra dura, muy emotiva, realista pero a la vez esperanzadora con un dibujo muy personal y de enorme calidad. Lo que más me ha sorprendido aún es que esta obra sea del 2006 cuando los temas que trata son terriblemente actuales: trabajos mal pagados, como sobrevivir, el hastío de algunos empleos, los sueños sin cumplir, no saber que hacer con tu vida, etc.
No importa si te gusta el manga o no, Solanin merece una oportunidad porque obras así hay pocas.
Es una obra dura, muy emotiva, realista pero a la vez esperanzadora con un dibujo muy personal y de enorme calidad. Lo que más me ha sorprendido aún es que esta obra sea del 2006 cuando los temas que trata son terriblemente actuales: trabajos mal pagados, como sobrevivir, el hastío de algunos empleos, los sueños sin cumplir, no saber que hacer con tu vida, etc.
No importa si te gusta el manga o no, Solanin merece una oportunidad porque obras así hay pocas.
January 15, 2022
آموزندهترین مانگایی بود که تا حالا خونده بودم.
خوندن این مانگا میتونه بهتون یاد بده چطوری زندگی کنید.
خوندن این مانگا میتونه بهتون یاد بده چطوری زندگی کنید.
September 19, 2011
Yes, Solanin is a manga. It is a comic book, from Japan. There is no escaping that. If that fact is insurmountable to you, then you do not get to read Solanin. Your loss.
That caveat out of the way, Solanin is well-worth your attention. It's a well-written and beautifully illustrated graphic novel about a group of young adults who are struggling to negotiate their lives past college. The main character is a disaffected OL (think administrative assistant) who took a job with a large company immediately after graduation. It pays well, but it makes her miserable, so she quits. This sparks a chain of events where herself and her friends are forced examine the meaning of responsibility, relationships, and freedom. When you don't fit into the 9 to 5 world, where do you fit instead?
Solanin excels in it's portrayal of a tale that could have been a collection of crushing cliches in the hands of a less talented writer. The art style toes the line between manga cuteness and more realistic cartooning styles to good effect, and the translation and localization of the book is well-done. As far as an independent comic release goes, Solanin hits all the right notes.
It is not a book for everyone. If the manga art style bothers you, you probably won't be able to get past the first couple of pages. It also does occasionally indulge a little sentimentality and self-pity for characters who may not deserve it. The twist that occurs two-thirds of the way through may strain your willingness to stick with the plot. But if you can get past these things, you'll be rewarded by the experience of reading a truly unique take on an ages-old trope.
In summary, if you are a fan of comics, Solanin deserves a place on your bookshelf. At least reserve it from the library if you don't believe me. It's a rewarding book, and anyone who has found themselves adrift with a diploma and no idea how to use it will find it rings true.
That caveat out of the way, Solanin is well-worth your attention. It's a well-written and beautifully illustrated graphic novel about a group of young adults who are struggling to negotiate their lives past college. The main character is a disaffected OL (think administrative assistant) who took a job with a large company immediately after graduation. It pays well, but it makes her miserable, so she quits. This sparks a chain of events where herself and her friends are forced examine the meaning of responsibility, relationships, and freedom. When you don't fit into the 9 to 5 world, where do you fit instead?
Solanin excels in it's portrayal of a tale that could have been a collection of crushing cliches in the hands of a less talented writer. The art style toes the line between manga cuteness and more realistic cartooning styles to good effect, and the translation and localization of the book is well-done. As far as an independent comic release goes, Solanin hits all the right notes.
It is not a book for everyone. If the manga art style bothers you, you probably won't be able to get past the first couple of pages. It also does occasionally indulge a little sentimentality and self-pity for characters who may not deserve it. The twist that occurs two-thirds of the way through may strain your willingness to stick with the plot. But if you can get past these things, you'll be rewarded by the experience of reading a truly unique take on an ages-old trope.
In summary, if you are a fan of comics, Solanin deserves a place on your bookshelf. At least reserve it from the library if you don't believe me. It's a rewarding book, and anyone who has found themselves adrift with a diploma and no idea how to use it will find it rings true.
December 13, 2009
Grabbed from here.
I think Solanin (ソラニン？）sets really high expectations and ultimately fails to deliver on them. There are lots of characters, all with unique backstories, but the interesting ones (non main characters) get pushed aside for the main plotline which I found kinda dull.
Temporally, the manga is really confusing. Manga typically signify a flashback via black borders around the edges. I couldn't tell what was a dream, what was a flashback and what was happening in "real-time." I'm still not really sure what happened in the story. Maybe that's intentional?
This book is definitely relevant to my interests as a mid 20-something going through a quarter life crisis. I have a feeling it would be more relevant if I was living in Japan. There are a number of cultural references and it's hard to pick up on them if you don't know about Japanese culture. For example, the job of Office Lady (OL) doesn't really exist in Western culture. Meiko is fighting against that culture of working at an office to find a hard working husband so she can quit. From a Western perspective, I think Japanese feel more "trapped" in their system than many of their Western counterparts do.
I think this is a first attempt from the author. In that case, it's good, but the amateurishness of it definitely shows as well. Solanin shows promise, and it isn't bad, but I feel it could have been a lot better.
I think Solanin (ソラニン？）sets really high expectations and ultimately fails to deliver on them. There are lots of characters, all with unique backstories, but the interesting ones (non main characters) get pushed aside for the main plotline which I found kinda dull.
Temporally, the manga is really confusing. Manga typically signify a flashback via black borders around the edges. I couldn't tell what was a dream, what was a flashback and what was happening in "real-time." I'm still not really sure what happened in the story. Maybe that's intentional?
This book is definitely relevant to my interests as a mid 20-something going through a quarter life crisis. I have a feeling it would be more relevant if I was living in Japan. There are a number of cultural references and it's hard to pick up on them if you don't know about Japanese culture. For example, the job of Office Lady (OL) doesn't really exist in Western culture. Meiko is fighting against that culture of working at an office to find a hard working husband so she can quit. From a Western perspective, I think Japanese feel more "trapped" in their system than many of their Western counterparts do.
I think this is a first attempt from the author. In that case, it's good, but the amateurishness of it definitely shows as well. Solanin shows promise, and it isn't bad, but I feel it could have been a lot better.
Read
March 18, 2020Una historia de transición a la edad adulta protagonizada por unos jóvenes tokiotas, pero que es perfectamente universal. Divertida, con gran ritmo a pesar de que nunca pone un pie fuera de lo cotidiano, cargada de ese vértigo vital de ver cómo la realidad engulle nuestras aspiraciones. No es maniquea ni deprimente, pese a algún golpe de efecto dramático que veo innecesario. Especial mención a la fuerza de las escenas musicales, tan bien dibujadas que pareces escuchar a la banda.
October 26, 2021
Meiko has recently graduated from college and hates her new job as an office worker. Her boyfriend Taneda gets paid chump change for working long hours as an illustrator and hates his job as well. Both of them are unsatisfied with the way their lives turned out and struggle to find reasons to be happy. Tired of such a dull and depressing life, Meiko decides to quit her job on a whim and get in touch with some old friends from college who used to play in a band together with Taneda. After reuniting, everyone learns that none of their lives worked out the way they wanted and they grow closer as each of them struggle to find meaning and fulfillment in their mundane lives. They get the band back together and confront their insecurities.
Solanin is less of a story and more of a look into the day-to-day struggles of young college graduates transitioning into adulthood. It's an awkward time in your life when you struggle to let go of your dreams and desires in order to move on and take on the responsibility of a grownup. It's hard, it's confusing and it's depressing as hell. The story goes through all the stages of grief. Denial, anger, bargaining, depression and then finally acceptance.
I'm sure everyone has felt like they weren't ready for the real world at some point in their lives. Everyone has experienced the fear of never becoming a healthy member of society or being able to gain true acceptance and fulfillment in life. It's okay to not be okay and it's okay to make stupid mistakes, so long as you don't let them take control of your life and define your entire being. Life doesn't follow a script and neither should you.
Inio Asano never fails to hit really close to home and take you through a rollercoaster of negative emotions before paying you off with a realistically hopeful and uplifting finale. His stories are simple yet they represent real life in the modern world frighteningly well, sometimes making you recall all kinds of sad, dark and embarrassing memories. He explores the lives of normal people and makes you feel as if you've been in their shoes many times before. Solanin is no exception.
***
If you're looking for some dark ambient music for reading horror, dark fantasy and other books like this one, then be sure to check out my YouTube Channel called Nightmarish Compositions: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPPs...
Solanin is less of a story and more of a look into the day-to-day struggles of young college graduates transitioning into adulthood. It's an awkward time in your life when you struggle to let go of your dreams and desires in order to move on and take on the responsibility of a grownup. It's hard, it's confusing and it's depressing as hell. The story goes through all the stages of grief. Denial, anger, bargaining, depression and then finally acceptance.
I'm sure everyone has felt like they weren't ready for the real world at some point in their lives. Everyone has experienced the fear of never becoming a healthy member of society or being able to gain true acceptance and fulfillment in life. It's okay to not be okay and it's okay to make stupid mistakes, so long as you don't let them take control of your life and define your entire being. Life doesn't follow a script and neither should you.
Inio Asano never fails to hit really close to home and take you through a rollercoaster of negative emotions before paying you off with a realistically hopeful and uplifting finale. His stories are simple yet they represent real life in the modern world frighteningly well, sometimes making you recall all kinds of sad, dark and embarrassing memories. He explores the lives of normal people and makes you feel as if you've been in their shoes many times before. Solanin is no exception.
***
If you're looking for some dark ambient music for reading horror, dark fantasy and other books like this one, then be sure to check out my YouTube Channel called Nightmarish Compositions: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPPs...
October 18, 2018
A manga about a couple in their early 20s, Meiko and Naruo, and their friends, as the various members of the group drift about and struggle to figure out this whole adulting thing. Insecurity and inner conflicts about selling out versus success plague many of the characters, until a tragedy acts as kind of a wake-up call to put at least some of them onto different paths. It's character-driven rather than plot-driven, but things are quite different at the end than the beginning. Almost a snapshot of a time and place, culturally and economically, as well as the new adult stage. It's very emotional without being overly dramatic, and I didn't stop thinking about it for days after I finished reading it. I'm not even a fan of slacker-type or disaffected/apathetic characters! Totally recommend this one.
Solanin was originally published, at least in Japan, as two volumes, but I think in the English translation it's only available in the one complete volume.
I read our library's copy, but just bought my own, so I could re-read - especially because a digital-only epilogue came out this summer that I want to read after I've refreshed my memory of all the characters.
Solanin was originally published, at least in Japan, as two volumes, but I think in the English translation it's only available in the one complete volume.
I read our library's copy, but just bought my own, so I could re-read - especially because a digital-only epilogue came out this summer that I want to read after I've refreshed my memory of all the characters.
June 26, 2018
This is a story about a girl who cried a...I mean it's about a girl who quits her job, lives with her mostly deadbeat boyfriend, and tries to find happiness in life.
This is basically a few months into the life of Meiko, a girl who's trying to figure out life. With her boyfriend only having a part time job she decides to push him into being something. At the same time she's doing that she's trying to figure herself out. Music is a central point that brought her and her boyfriend together but also all their friends. Will they be able to use that music to become something more than what they are?
Good: This is a slice of life story and does it mostly well. The major twist is easy to see coming but still lands. I also thought the dialog was mostly well done and both funny and sad.
Bad: The dialog bubbles were hard to follow in this one and some scenes did drag pretty far.
Overall this is a real interesting story. While I didn't love it I enjoyed it throughout and was invested in their life. A 3.5 out of 5.
This is basically a few months into the life of Meiko, a girl who's trying to figure out life. With her boyfriend only having a part time job she decides to push him into being something. At the same time she's doing that she's trying to figure herself out. Music is a central point that brought her and her boyfriend together but also all their friends. Will they be able to use that music to become something more than what they are?
Good: This is a slice of life story and does it mostly well. The major twist is easy to see coming but still lands. I also thought the dialog was mostly well done and both funny and sad.
Bad: The dialog bubbles were hard to follow in this one and some scenes did drag pretty far.
Overall this is a real interesting story. While I didn't love it I enjoyed it throughout and was invested in their life. A 3.5 out of 5.
November 20, 2019
5/5
Ayayayay. Este es mi manga favoritsísimo de la vida entera; a pesar de esto, desde que salí del liceo que no le echaba una ojeada, así que cuando vi que bookdepository estaba con descuento dije mmm por qué no.
Esta vez me pegó fuertísmo (lo más probable es que se deba a mi contexto actual).
Me fue inevitable verme en Meiko; me vi en sus errores, en sus miedos. Vulnerable, ¿insegura?
Yo sé que siempre se dice que Inio Asano es emo porque sí, sus historias tienen mucho de desesperanzador, pero también de crecimiento y autoconocimiento en ese páramo horrible que está en el camino de la dulce adolescencia a la gris adultez.
La Cata que leyó esto en primero medio jamás se imaginó que estaría viviendo sola desde los 20, y estudiando lo que estudia. La Cata de hace 8 años no es ni parecida a la Cata de hoy, y agradezco muchísimo esto. Agradezco esta historia, y todos los caminos que me llevaron a ella.
Ayayayay. Este es mi manga favoritsísimo de la vida entera; a pesar de esto, desde que salí del liceo que no le echaba una ojeada, así que cuando vi que bookdepository estaba con descuento dije mmm por qué no.
Esta vez me pegó fuertísmo (lo más probable es que se deba a mi contexto actual).
Me fue inevitable verme en Meiko; me vi en sus errores, en sus miedos. Vulnerable, ¿insegura?
Yo sé que siempre se dice que Inio Asano es emo porque sí, sus historias tienen mucho de desesperanzador, pero también de crecimiento y autoconocimiento en ese páramo horrible que está en el camino de la dulce adolescencia a la gris adultez.
La Cata que leyó esto en primero medio jamás se imaginó que estaría viviendo sola desde los 20, y estudiando lo que estudia. La Cata de hace 8 años no es ni parecida a la Cata de hoy, y agradezco muchísimo esto. Agradezco esta historia, y todos los caminos que me llevaron a ella.
April 15, 2010
Only two books have ever made me cry- actually, bawl, while reading them. The first was Kafka's The Metamorphosis. The second was Solanin. Not only are the pictures in this graphic novel so beautifully done, the story stays with the reader long after the last page has been turned. Every recent college grad or early 20-something should read this book.
It follows the lives of Meiko and her boyfriend Taneda as they drift through life and contemplate the years of uncertainty following graduation. The trip is not always pleasant-these characters hurt and feel and lose, but finding out what is truly "precious" is the greatest realization of all.
I simply cannot recommend this book highly enough. It reads manga style- right to left, but even if graphic novels aren't your thing, I still recommend reading this book.
It follows the lives of Meiko and her boyfriend Taneda as they drift through life and contemplate the years of uncertainty following graduation. The trip is not always pleasant-these characters hurt and feel and lose, but finding out what is truly "precious" is the greatest realization of all.
I simply cannot recommend this book highly enough. It reads manga style- right to left, but even if graphic novels aren't your thing, I still recommend reading this book.
February 3, 2021
Asano abusa del sentimentalismo para presentar a unos personajes que formulan todas sus angustias vitales a través de la voz interior y los diálogos. No hay espacio ni para la imaginación ni para lo sutil ni para interpretaciones simbólicas. Todo está explicito, en primera persona y preparado para que entre por las venas y se vaya directamente al cerebro en forma de proyección. Luego, una vez se ha producido la fusión entre la mente del personaje y la del lector, Asano se encarga de jugar con las escenas para adentrarse en el drama de la forma más efectista posible, casi rozando lo tramposo. Así no vale, que dirían algunos...
Los dibujos eso sí, son brillantes y la caracterización y la expresividad de los personajes está muy lograda. Dicho esto, su talento como ilustrador no compensa el sentimentalismo de brocha gorda al que nos somete en esta obra.
Los dibujos eso sí, son brillantes y la caracterización y la expresividad de los personajes está muy lograda. Dicho esto, su talento como ilustrador no compensa el sentimentalismo de brocha gorda al que nos somete en esta obra.
September 14, 2018
Solanin is a slightly dark, slice of life story about a young couple struggling to make it after graduating from university. As a 20-something myself, this was a pretty relatable story as I still feel like maybe I could be accomplishing more with my life?
Solanin had it's heavy moments, but I absolutely loved how real it all felt.
I've been loving all of Inio Asano's work lately and I'll definitely be reading more very soon, including the epilogue to Solanin that I picked up at TCAF earlier this year!
June 17, 2016
This demands its way onto my Favorite Sequential Art List, right up there with Persepolis, Bone, and Kingdom Come. It's unlike any of those, in that it uses episodic comics to tell Slice of Life, about a struggling band that's probably better off giving up and keeping their day jobs, but that'd crush their souls. Meiko and Taneda have been sweethearts for longer than their parents approve, united by a support for finding themselves in music. Their futures aren't going anywhere, and the drama they're facing is if being together for this day, week, and year is enough.
This is put into sharp repose by an early chapter of an old man who's constantly trying to mail letters, often multiple times a day. When the band approaches, he explains his wife wanted to know everything he did. Since she died, writing descriptions for her is the only way he can honor her wishes - and getting the notes the next day helps him feel like he's lived. It's a great wake-up call to tweens who think they aren't accomplishing enough when they're surrounded by each other.
Their goal isn't to change the landscape of music - it's really just to express themselves in a life that suppresses all creativity. Anyone with a 9-to-5 can relate to hunting for that outlet, and the beauty of Solanin is that Meiko and Taneda manage to share that with others. The band isn't supremely talented so much as they're on similar wavelengths, able to support each other in emotional tragedies and to play along in the weirdest shenanigans. It's the sort of core group you'd easily root for to win a music competition or giant recording contract, but this book is more compelling because they want something simpler. They want the release that only comes from working together in an industry that doesn't appreciate that.
This is put into sharp repose by an early chapter of an old man who's constantly trying to mail letters, often multiple times a day. When the band approaches, he explains his wife wanted to know everything he did. Since she died, writing descriptions for her is the only way he can honor her wishes - and getting the notes the next day helps him feel like he's lived. It's a great wake-up call to tweens who think they aren't accomplishing enough when they're surrounded by each other.
Their goal isn't to change the landscape of music - it's really just to express themselves in a life that suppresses all creativity. Anyone with a 9-to-5 can relate to hunting for that outlet, and the beauty of Solanin is that Meiko and Taneda manage to share that with others. The band isn't supremely talented so much as they're on similar wavelengths, able to support each other in emotional tragedies and to play along in the weirdest shenanigans. It's the sort of core group you'd easily root for to win a music competition or giant recording contract, but this book is more compelling because they want something simpler. They want the release that only comes from working together in an industry that doesn't appreciate that.
October 2, 2019
Four and a half.
I started out weird with this author. Some time ago I decided to read his "Oyasumi Punpun", an angsty, often dark slice-of-life about a kid from a broken home, who falls in love with a weird girl. It was one of the highest rated manga in many lists, so naturally I had to try. However, the author decided to depict the protagonist (and his family) literally as the caricature of a bird with the expressivity of the twitter logo, and that if I remember correctly didn't speak at all. The gimmick got old fast, although I appreciated many other aspects about the story. I abandoned it for now after a few volumes.
"Solanin" is two volumes long and deals with a couple in their early twenties who face the chasm of becoming full blown adults. The protagonist, the girl with the smoochable face, has the common character flaw of being unable to stick to anything. She hasn't got any particular talent, although she wouldn't have tried hard enough to develop any interest. She moved from a small town to Tokyo and got a job mostly because it's what she's supposed to do, but she can't adapt to the routine and atmosphere of an office where she does nothing of interest. She craves for freedom, even if it's the opportunity to do nothing at all. She lives with her boyfriend, who works part time at a job he dislikes but that supports his main passion, which is making music. He sings and plays guitar along with a couple of local goofballs: a womanizing chubby guy who might never leave college, and an awkwardly hairy sort of punk guy who works at a grocery store. The issue with the protagonist's boyfriend, a common one at that, is that his talent doesn't measure up to his ambition. He'd rather die than submit to the nine to five (or eight to seven if you are Japanese, I guess). You realize quickly that his band has no future, that they are just kids playing around until they can't even afford to pay for groceries.
The drawings are often exceptional, and have that realistic vibe that only a busy team behind the scenes produces for some mangas. Additionally, the illustrators did a great job making you feel that these are people living their lives, from how they change their style (clothes, hairstyle, etc.) to what they are shown engaged in. And the girls are really cute, which is always a plus.
The plot kicks into gear when the protagonist quits her job and faces unemployment without a single clue about what she's going to do with her life. For a while she enjoys her freedom, but soon she begins feeling like a ghost and worrying that her money is going to run out. We follow her, her boyfriend and his pals in an existential journey. Is work enslavement truly their only option unless they are extraordinarily lucky and talented? What would make them happy? Their existentialism never get into suicidal territory; even when things get quite tough they seem generally chill about it, which is a tremendous contrast with "Welcome to the NHK", my favorite manga/anime dealing with unemployment, social isolation, existentialism and suicidal ideation.
In any case, the protagonist can't stand watching her boyfriend waste away at a job he hates, and just going at his music half-heartedly (mostly because he realizes they don't have the talent, and he is mature enough to face he needs a solid plan for the future). That convinces the guy to quit his job and give his band an honest try. They'll produce songs and practice like hell, record a demo and see if they were destined to be amongst the lucky ones.
A significant part of what I love about this story is that it shows you that .
First thing that came to mind regarding the two distinct sides to this story, separated by volumes, is the OST to "Welcome to the NHK", which are titled respectively "Welcome to the Sunny Side" and "Welcome to the Dark Side" (just because, here's one of its songs). In this second half of "Solanin" the protagonist struggles with solitude but unable to process or even commit to the grief. She's deadened and can't figure out a path forward, until someone tells her that .
On a personal note (I seem to write plenty of personal notes recently; I guess this is my diary), back in 2011-2012 I wrote around 210,000 words of a story like this. A young, mostly naïve girl with a peculiar mind and more passion than talent joined her boyfriend's mediocre band, moved to a big city and clashed against a world that wouldn't accommodate someone like her. Its turning point even tinted the second half of the story, during which she struggled on her own while holding on to a loveless relationship and suffering from increasing delusions. As usual with my stories, it pushed down further and further into psychotic territory. I never got to write the draft for the second half, although I had planned every scene. In 2018 I wrote the first draft of another novel that featured most of that story. I was close to finishing the draft when I felt that psychologically I had gotten out of writing it all that I needed, and there was no point in polishing it further and publishing it because it would never get an audience. I haven't written anything else since. In relation to "Solanin", for most of my youth my thoughts mirrored those of the protagonist's boyfriend: I would rather die than submit to a deadening job with no hope of anything in the horizon that would move me or fulfill me on a substantial level. Now, as a 33 year old, older than I thought I'd ever be, I've read this story while on the train to and from work, and I live to grow old and make money, with the occasional foray into VR porn which I'm sure is going to destroy civilization. To quote myself, and I thought I would never go as low as quoting myself, it's just a note in the symphony of pain of organic life, and I should be content that I get to work and earn money which saves me from facing that I'm hanging above the natural hell of killing or being killed to survive another day. Thankfully I'm too exhausted to care.
I started out weird with this author. Some time ago I decided to read his "Oyasumi Punpun", an angsty, often dark slice-of-life about a kid from a broken home, who falls in love with a weird girl. It was one of the highest rated manga in many lists, so naturally I had to try. However, the author decided to depict the protagonist (and his family) literally as the caricature of a bird with the expressivity of the twitter logo, and that if I remember correctly didn't speak at all. The gimmick got old fast, although I appreciated many other aspects about the story. I abandoned it for now after a few volumes.
"Solanin" is two volumes long and deals with a couple in their early twenties who face the chasm of becoming full blown adults. The protagonist, the girl with the smoochable face, has the common character flaw of being unable to stick to anything. She hasn't got any particular talent, although she wouldn't have tried hard enough to develop any interest. She moved from a small town to Tokyo and got a job mostly because it's what she's supposed to do, but she can't adapt to the routine and atmosphere of an office where she does nothing of interest. She craves for freedom, even if it's the opportunity to do nothing at all. She lives with her boyfriend, who works part time at a job he dislikes but that supports his main passion, which is making music. He sings and plays guitar along with a couple of local goofballs: a womanizing chubby guy who might never leave college, and an awkwardly hairy sort of punk guy who works at a grocery store. The issue with the protagonist's boyfriend, a common one at that, is that his talent doesn't measure up to his ambition. He'd rather die than submit to the nine to five (or eight to seven if you are Japanese, I guess). You realize quickly that his band has no future, that they are just kids playing around until they can't even afford to pay for groceries.
The drawings are often exceptional, and have that realistic vibe that only a busy team behind the scenes produces for some mangas. Additionally, the illustrators did a great job making you feel that these are people living their lives, from how they change their style (clothes, hairstyle, etc.) to what they are shown engaged in. And the girls are really cute, which is always a plus.
The plot kicks into gear when the protagonist quits her job and faces unemployment without a single clue about what she's going to do with her life. For a while she enjoys her freedom, but soon she begins feeling like a ghost and worrying that her money is going to run out. We follow her, her boyfriend and his pals in an existential journey. Is work enslavement truly their only option unless they are extraordinarily lucky and talented? What would make them happy? Their existentialism never get into suicidal territory; even when things get quite tough they seem generally chill about it, which is a tremendous contrast with "Welcome to the NHK", my favorite manga/anime dealing with unemployment, social isolation, existentialism and suicidal ideation.
In any case, the protagonist can't stand watching her boyfriend waste away at a job he hates, and just going at his music half-heartedly (mostly because he realizes they don't have the talent, and he is mature enough to face he needs a solid plan for the future). That convinces the guy to quit his job and give his band an honest try. They'll produce songs and practice like hell, record a demo and see if they were destined to be amongst the lucky ones.
A significant part of what I love about this story is that it shows you that .
First thing that came to mind regarding the two distinct sides to this story, separated by volumes, is the OST to "Welcome to the NHK", which are titled respectively "Welcome to the Sunny Side" and "Welcome to the Dark Side" (just because, here's one of its songs). In this second half of "Solanin" the protagonist struggles with solitude but unable to process or even commit to the grief. She's deadened and can't figure out a path forward, until someone tells her that .
On a personal note (I seem to write plenty of personal notes recently; I guess this is my diary), back in 2011-2012 I wrote around 210,000 words of a story like this. A young, mostly naïve girl with a peculiar mind and more passion than talent joined her boyfriend's mediocre band, moved to a big city and clashed against a world that wouldn't accommodate someone like her. Its turning point even tinted the second half of the story, during which she struggled on her own while holding on to a loveless relationship and suffering from increasing delusions. As usual with my stories, it pushed down further and further into psychotic territory. I never got to write the draft for the second half, although I had planned every scene. In 2018 I wrote the first draft of another novel that featured most of that story. I was close to finishing the draft when I felt that psychologically I had gotten out of writing it all that I needed, and there was no point in polishing it further and publishing it because it would never get an audience. I haven't written anything else since. In relation to "Solanin", for most of my youth my thoughts mirrored those of the protagonist's boyfriend: I would rather die than submit to a deadening job with no hope of anything in the horizon that would move me or fulfill me on a substantial level. Now, as a 33 year old, older than I thought I'd ever be, I've read this story while on the train to and from work, and I live to grow old and make money, with the occasional foray into VR porn which I'm sure is going to destroy civilization. To quote myself, and I thought I would never go as low as quoting myself, it's just a note in the symphony of pain of organic life, and I should be content that I get to work and earn money which saves me from facing that I'm hanging above the natural hell of killing or being killed to survive another day. Thankfully I'm too exhausted to care.
March 15, 2020
Hoy les traigo la reseña de un manga que leí hace unos días y que llevaba bastante tiempo en mi lista de pendientes ¿Que puedo decir? La verdad es que este manga me ha decepcionado bastante y no porque sea malo, sino porque esperaba otro tipo de historía. Por supuesto, ya sabía que se trataba de un slice of life, más adulto, enfocado en el desarrollo de personajes. Sin embargo, debido a que es una de mis temáticas favoritas, es algo de lo que he leído y visto bastante, en muchos formatos distintos.
En general la historia está bastante bien, los dibujos son geniales, me gusta su manejo de las viñetas, sobre todo, en el climax de la historia. Hay un par de secuencias bastante poderosas que dejan ver una gran expresividad en sus ilustraciones.
Los personajes estan bien desarrollados, son simpáticos, aunque tienen las personalidades estandar en este tipo de historias. Los están muy bien acoplados al estilo de dibujo y me gusta como el autor se fija en los detalles de la ropa o accesorios.
Sin embargo, a pesar de que todo está muy bien, no consiguió destacarse demasiado entre mis lecturas. Solanin tiene un mensaje poderoso, pero se pierde un poco debido a los sucesos y giros que presenta la historia. No es un problema demasiado evidente, que te impida leer, de hecho, con todo esto, creo que el autor tenía muy bien planeada la trama, sin embargo cuando llegamos a la conclusión, esta es tan desabrida que arruina toda la experiencia hasta ese momento.
De nuevo, no es que sea un mal final, pero no es el tipo de final que a mi me gusta y el resto de la historia no se me quedó tan grabada como para ignorar su conclusión. Le doy 2.5/5.
En general la historia está bastante bien, los dibujos son geniales, me gusta su manejo de las viñetas, sobre todo, en el climax de la historia. Hay un par de secuencias bastante poderosas que dejan ver una gran expresividad en sus ilustraciones.
Los personajes estan bien desarrollados, son simpáticos, aunque tienen las personalidades estandar en este tipo de historias. Los están muy bien acoplados al estilo de dibujo y me gusta como el autor se fija en los detalles de la ropa o accesorios.
Sin embargo, a pesar de que todo está muy bien, no consiguió destacarse demasiado entre mis lecturas. Solanin tiene un mensaje poderoso, pero se pierde un poco debido a los sucesos y giros que presenta la historia. No es un problema demasiado evidente, que te impida leer, de hecho, con todo esto, creo que el autor tenía muy bien planeada la trama, sin embargo cuando llegamos a la conclusión, esta es tan desabrida que arruina toda la experiencia hasta ese momento.
De nuevo, no es que sea un mal final, pero no es el tipo de final que a mi me gusta y el resto de la historia no se me quedó tan grabada como para ignorar su conclusión. Le doy 2.5/5.
December 15, 2010
Summary: A group of early-20-somethings struggle with life in general in present-day Japan. Should dreams be sold out for a better apartment? How do you measure whether a relationship is "worth it"? What does it mean to be an adult? Meiko, her boyfriend Taneda, and the other members of the music club they belonged to in school all struggle with their own difficulties in this illumination of the growing pains we face when we try to grow up.
Characters: This book rides on characterization. The overall character group is diverse in personality, but they are linked by their uncertainty and occasional apathy. The author deliberately chose a very ordinary group of people who would blend into the background if you saw them in public. The main character by a nose is Meiko, who grows from a frightened, questioning young woman into a slightly less frightened, still questioning young woman. Still, over the course of the book, Meiko acquires a hard-won outer confidence and a measure of peace. The supporting cast includes her boyfriend Taneda, who is torn between staying in a paying job and trying to find success with his band, and his bandmates Kato, a good-natured loser, and Rip, who has a job, a bit more certainty than his friends, but still possesses a quiet unease and a crush on Meiko.
Plot: The plot is character-driven and extremely personal. Characters make choices, and those choices impact the lives of the people around them. Halfway through the book, a terrible tragedy changes everyone's outlook on the world. Despite the personal minutiae, or perhaps because of it, the book is a fascinating look at a generation.
Art: The life and energy in the art is understated but powerful. While this book relies heavily on dialogue and inner monologue, the art is definitely not superfluous.
Writing/Dialogue: Somehow Asano manages to keep the dialogue and inner thoughts here both true to the characters and poignant. While rarely uplifting or cheerful, this book is never a burden to read.
Ending: Is there hope in the ending, or only more uncertainty? Where will the characters go from here? It all depends on your point of view.
What more did I want?: I wanted closure in the ending, even though it would have ruined the book. I strongly identify with these unsure, drifting kids at this point in my life, and I wanted to see things work out for them.
Characters: This book rides on characterization. The overall character group is diverse in personality, but they are linked by their uncertainty and occasional apathy. The author deliberately chose a very ordinary group of people who would blend into the background if you saw them in public. The main character by a nose is Meiko, who grows from a frightened, questioning young woman into a slightly less frightened, still questioning young woman. Still, over the course of the book, Meiko acquires a hard-won outer confidence and a measure of peace. The supporting cast includes her boyfriend Taneda, who is torn between staying in a paying job and trying to find success with his band, and his bandmates Kato, a good-natured loser, and Rip, who has a job, a bit more certainty than his friends, but still possesses a quiet unease and a crush on Meiko.
Plot: The plot is character-driven and extremely personal. Characters make choices, and those choices impact the lives of the people around them. Halfway through the book, a terrible tragedy changes everyone's outlook on the world. Despite the personal minutiae, or perhaps because of it, the book is a fascinating look at a generation.
Art: The life and energy in the art is understated but powerful. While this book relies heavily on dialogue and inner monologue, the art is definitely not superfluous.
Writing/Dialogue: Somehow Asano manages to keep the dialogue and inner thoughts here both true to the characters and poignant. While rarely uplifting or cheerful, this book is never a burden to read.
Ending: Is there hope in the ending, or only more uncertainty? Where will the characters go from here? It all depends on your point of view.
What more did I want?: I wanted closure in the ending, even though it would have ruined the book. I strongly identify with these unsure, drifting kids at this point in my life, and I wanted to see things work out for them.
January 10, 2020
auch. que loco haber leído esto ahora, en plena crisis existencial psicoadolescente (pq ya no me queda adolescencia). pero una sale realmente en algún momento de esa crisis? supongo que sólo se mitiga un poco y se aprende a vivir con ella. me emocionó mucho, incluso con su tópico romántico y todo. muchos uwu feels.
February 17, 2016
"Let me photograph you in this light
In case it is the last time
That we might be exactly like we were
Before we realized
We were sad of getting old
It made us restless
Oh I'm so mad I'm getting old
It makes me reckless"
Adele - When we were young.
Meiko y Naruo, una pareja recien salida de la universidad, se encuentran en trabajos que no les gustan, pero que les da suficiente dinero para pagar la renta y mantener sus hobbies. Pero un día Meiko regresa de un mal día de trabajo y decide renunciar.
Este libro es la clara representación de tener 20 y tanto de años y preguntarse: ¿qué quiero de mi vida? ¿A donde voy con todo esto? ¿Lo que hago porque realmente lo quiero o porque es lo que los demás esperan que haga?
Es dulce, romántico, gracioso, triste, una montaña rusa de emociones. Me animo a decir que va a ser uno de mis mangas favoritos de todos los tiempos. Está tan bien escrito que siento que en algún lugar todos los personajes siguen con sus vidas, como amigos que uno conoció bien, pero que ya no ve tanto porque la vida es asi.
De alguna forma me recuerda a NANA, o una versión más realista y seria de Scott pilgrim. Lo recomiendo a todo el mundo, en especial a mayores de 20 años.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,236 reviews